Debate: Is Leaking Information Acceptable in Some Cases?

Listenwise helps teachers use stories from public radio in their classrooms. To find more stories and lessons for your middle and high school ELA, social studies, and science classrooms you can sign up for a free Listenwise account! Teaching Strategies for using Listenwise.

Story Description:

It is easier today for whistleblowers to leak confidential information to the press as a result of several new high-tech tools for leaking. Using encrypted messaging apps and email services, ordinary people are now able to give anonymous tips to news outlets. The Washington Post, New York Times and ProPublica have published guides that outline different options for sending in anonymous tips. At the same time, technology is also allowing the government and law enforcement to seize the personal information and communication history of whistleblowers and journalists. Listen to learn more about how ordinary people, as well as government officials, are using new technology to communicate without surveillance.

Listening Comprehension Questions:

• What changes have made it easier for people to leak information to the press?
• Why do you think anonymous tips are so important to news outlets?
• How are government and law enforcement able to use technology to combat leaks?
• Do you think encrypted apps like Signal are doing something good for society?
• In what ways do you think the increase of surveillance has sparked an increase of apps that make it easier to leak information?

Classroom Discussion Themes:

• Do you believe there is a problem with government officials using encrypted messaging apps to keep their communication private? Why or why not?
• Debate: Do you believe leaks are “criminal” or is leaking information acceptable in some cases?